Question: Should illegal immigrants be offered a path to legalization?
Argument for the "No" side
Illegal immigrants already have a clear path to legal immigration. Why do we need more laws to offer a 'carrot' to immigration when the laws we already have could be use and should be used. After all this is a Nation of immigrants.

Posted by starcad on 2/20/2008
Score Details  Score  Up vs Down
Yes Side 50 % 1 vs 1
No Side 50 % 1 vs 1
Undecided 66 % 2 vs 1

Post a Rebuttal

Note that each rebuttal should be a concise self-contained argument limited to 600 characters.
If more space is needed, you may post additional (self-contained) rebuttals.
You may also post the title and address of a hyperlink to support your rebuttal (optional).


Maximum Length 600 characters.




http://

Maximum Length 255 characters.